Friday 29 March 2024 | 00:01

Opinion: Western sanctions against Russia promise contradictory consequences for Belarus’ economy

23.08.2014  |  Economy   |  Volha Charnysh, BelarusDigest,  
Opinion: Western sanctions against Russia promise contradictory consequences for Belarus’ economy

In the short run, decline in Moscow-EU relations seem to open new export prospects for Belarus. But these minor benefits for Belarusan economy can be outweighed by negative impacts in the long run.

Earlier this month, Russia introduced a full embargo on imports of meat, fish, dairy, fruit and vegetables from the European Union (EU), United States, Australia, Canada and Norway.

Moscow sought to retaliate for the sanctions imposed by the West following the downing of the Malaysian Airlines flight over Eastern Ukraine in July. The food ban went into effect immediately.

Belarus, itself no stranger to Western sanctions, took the news in stride, promising to increase Belarusan food exports to Russia.

Whether the food embargo indeed holds substantial economic opportunities for Belarus, however, is not clear, especially if Russia will be able to fully monitor Belarus’ exports and re-exports. Russia has already accused Belarus of lacking capacity to monitor exports, reportedly identifying 11 violations at the Russian-Belarusan border last week.

Even if it does, the benefits for the Belarusan economy in the short run may be outweighed by negative impacts in the long run. Sustained sanctions will eventually produce an economic downturn in Russia that will also ripple through the Belarusan economy.

Belarus is getting ready to cash in

Last year, Russia imported $15.8 billion worth of agricultural products from the EU, as well as $1.3 billion worth of foodstuffs from the US. Following the recent imposition of sanctions, Western media reported that truckloads of fruit had been detained at the Russian border and left to rot.

Reacting to the panic of Greek farmers, who were hit hardest by the embargo, the EU commission promised to compensate peach and nectarine growers.

Farmers and producers in non-EU states like Belarus are much more cheerful. They view the embargo as a lucrative opportunity to boost exports to Russia. But how exactly is Minsk going to benefit?

On August 11, President Lukashenka said that Belarus, which enjoys a customs-free zone and shares a long border with Russia, would fulfill all obligations to protect the market of the union state as regards the transit of goods across its territory.

He also promised to increase food exports to Russia. At the same time, Lukashenka did not follow Russia’s ban. Neither did the third member of the customs union – Kazakhstan.

The hard limits of Belarusan food industry

Despite Belarus’s promises, the opportunities for increasing food exports to Russia without violating the embargo are highly constrained in the short run. Belarus cannot breed more cows or grow more potatoes overnight.

Therefore, any immediate increases of food exports to Russia, short of flaunting the embargo by simply relabeling European products, will lead to the disappearance of produce in the domestic market.

Belarus’ reaction to the Russian-Georgian war provides a blueprint that can be followed this time as well.

Back in 2008, Georgian wine and mineral water easily found their way into Russia via Belarus. Russia chose to look the other way because it needed allies.

Whether Belarus will cash in on the embargo depends primarily on Russia’s willingness to monitor and enforce food exports from Belarus.

A quick look at the long list of Belarusan food exports shows just how difficult it is to shut down the flow of Western food into Russia without undermining Russia’s trade relationship with Belarus.

Data from Belstat, for example, shows that, from January to May of this year, Belarus exported 11,921 tons of citrus fruit, 149.9 tons of Atlantic Salmon, and 304 tons of bananas into Russia.

Even greater quantities of Western produce are exported to Russia after being processed in Belarus. The Belarusan firm Santa-Bremor, owned by the oligarch and Lukashenka confidante Aleksandr Moshensky, is a poignant example.

The company sells all of its products under the “made in Belarus” label. However, its products contain salmon, caviar, and seafood, which cannot be found in landlocked Belarus. Belarusan media recently reported that Santa-Bremor increased its exports to Russia by 30% over the past week alone.

Belarus is also home to a number of fruit and vegetable processing plants, which rely on Western produce and sell the finished products to Russia. Allowing these companies to continue exports technically violates the embargo. But exports continue under the “made in Belarus” label, in part because Russia knows that prohibiting such exports would hurt the Belarusan economy and crack the foundations of the Customs Union.

Recognizing that a number of vehicles with perishable projects were stuck at the Belarusan border, Lukashenka has already proposed that products banned from entering the Russian market be sent to Belarusan processing facilities.

Because the Russian-Belarusan border can be crossed without customs checks, Western products can reach Russia via many other routes. In fact, thousands of Russians may simply choose to go shopping in Belarus more often.

Reacting to the likely increases in domestic food prices, Belarusans, in turn, may increase their shopping trips to Poland, where food is already cheaper than in Belarus.

How far will Russia go to enforce the embargo?

Circumventing Economic Customs Union rules when they hurt the national interest seems to be a recurring pattern in Belarus’s behaviour. Last year, Russia failed to secure Belarus’ and Kazakhstan’s support in imposing restrictions on Ukrainian goods in the even that Kiev would sign the Association Agreement.

Russia raised the issue again in June at the meeting of the Eurasian Economic Commission but its proposal, to no avail. Thus, Belarus was able to insulate itself from the economic consequences of Russia’s trade war with Ukraine and may even benefit from re-exporting not only Western, but also Ukrainian goods to Russia.

Moscow certainly has enough power to pressure Belarus into compliance. However, it seems reluctant to do so at the time when its influence in the post-Soviet space is threatened and Belarus is a valuable ally.

Early signals from Russia indicate that it is not ready to look the other way. Just this week, Russia’s Federal Service for veterinary and phytosanitary control (Rosselhoznadzor) has said Belarus was unable to control exports of prohibited foodstuffs to Russia. According to Rosselhoznadzor, Minsk’s failure to control exports “threatens Russia’s food security”. According to UNIAN, the Russian side identified 11 violations of the ban by Belarus between 11 August  and 15 August alone.

Tellingly, however, Moscow did not blame Belarus directly. Rosselhoznadzor’s official statement has placed the responsibility on the EU – for not labeling the products correctly. It decided to warn Belarus rather than criticize its directly.

The long-term impact of Western sanctions

The deterioration of Moscow’s relationship with the West has contradictory consequences for Belarus’ economy. In the short term, the conflict has opened new export opportunities for Belarus.

Over time, though, Belarus’ economic dependence on its larger neighbour means that Moscow’s economic problems sooner or later will ripple through the Belarusan economy.

The Russian stock market and the ruble have already fallen, and Russia's growth forecasts for the year look bleak. Belarus may feel the effects of Moscow’s economic downturn in the not-so-distant future.

Russia’s economic problems could, for example, weaken the Belarusan machine-building industry. Large export-oriented plants in this sector, such as the Minsk automobile plant, stand to lose a lot of money if Russia’s demand slows.

The Belarusan financial sector is also vulnerable. Four Russian state-owned banks that are targeted by Western sanctions -- Sberbank, Vnesheconombank (VEB), Gazprombank, and VTB Bank -- all have operations in Belarus.

Originally published at BelarusDigest

Other news section «Economy»

Leanid Zaika: Minsk decided to beat the Kremlin by Iranian oil
Leanid Zaika: Minsk decided to beat the Kremlin by Iranian oil
There are no strategic goals behind the purchase of Iranian oil, believes economist Leanid Zaika.
Stanislau Bagdankevich: The living standard will continue to fall in 2017, and possibly in 2018
Stanislau Bagdankevich: The living standard will continue to fall in 2017, and possibly in 2018
In 2017, Belarus will have to pay about $ 5 billion debts, which may affect the level of welfare negatively.
Leu Margolin: Industry cannot rise from its knees
Leu Margolin: Industry cannot rise from its knees
Although 30 percent of Belarusian enterprises can still be revived through urgent structural reforms.
Stanislau Bagdankevich: Next year will be harsh
Stanislau Bagdankevich: Next year will be harsh
Stagnation will continue in 2017, the standard of living will not rise, and the banking system may experience a crisis.
Andrei Yeliseyeu: Russia cannot impose quotas on the Belarusian dairy products supply
Andrei Yeliseyeu: Russia cannot impose quotas on the Belarusian dairy products supply
Belarus has already agreed to reduce the level of state support to agricultural producers in the framework of the Eurasian agreements.  
Leu Margolin: It is impossible to bring back the 500 dollars salary
Leu Margolin: It is impossible to bring back the 500 dollars salary
The authorities will start pressuring businesses to make them raise salaries.
Uladzimir Kavalkin: Drop in income? Salaries are finally becoming adequate to the economy state
Uladzimir Kavalkin: Drop in income? Salaries are finally becoming adequate to the economy state
Income may drop even a little bit more, but it will not be anything dramatic - within a few percent, expert believes.
Leu Marholin: In 2017, the probability of economic growth is close to zero
Leu Marholin: In 2017, the probability of economic growth is close to zero
In 2016, Belarusian authorities were expecting growth, too. However, the economy is going down.
EBRD will prepare five state companies for privatization
EBRD will prepare five state companies for privatization
The Belarusian government has invited the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD) to prepare five large state-owned companies for privatization.
 Leu Marholin: We are heading full speed to the new nineties
 Leu Marholin: We are heading full speed to the new nineties
Regression of the Belarusian economy combined with the inertness of the government will make us recall the worst years.  
Uladzimir Kavalkin: Statistics on unemployment and real unemployment are poles apart in Belarus
Uladzimir Kavalkin: Statistics on unemployment and real unemployment are poles apart in Belarus
Officially, the unemployment in our country is reducing – if judging by the number of registrations at the labor exchange; however, the number of jobs doesn’t increase in the economy.
Leanid Zaika: Decline in prices on gas should lead to the reduction in utility costs
Leanid Zaika: Decline in prices on gas should lead to the reduction in utility costs
In the situation of cheaper prices on gas Lukashenka's decree on non-cash housing subsidies looks weird.
Point of view: Defence industry in Belarus evolved from helpless to a weighty branch of economy
Point of view: Defence industry in Belarus evolved from helpless to a weighty branch of economy
Recently Belarus State Military Industrial Committee announced that in the first half of 2016 its enterprises earned a net profit of $80m, thus over-fulfilling the assigned export plans by a quarter.
Leu Marholin: It looks like the Belarusian PM has got a fortuneteller
Leu Marholin: It looks like the Belarusian PM has got a fortuneteller
The fall of the economy will continue in 2016; we should hardly expect growth in 2017.
Why with the success abroad, Belarus’ agriculture keeps failing at home?
Why with the success abroad, Belarus’ agriculture keeps failing at home?
Poor economic conditions in the countryside, restrictions, unfair competition, inefficiency of state-owned agricultural enterprises also contribute to this ‘success story’, writes Aliaksandr Filipau.
Viktar Marhelau: We killed consumer demand inside the country
Viktar Marhelau: We killed consumer demand inside the country
In the situation of everyone’s impoverishment administrative procedures are now being perceived painfully.
Opinion: The question of what role China can play in Belarusian development remains open
Opinion: The question of what role China can play in Belarusian development remains open
On 20 June Lukashenka met with vice-chair and president of the Chinese CITIC Group Corporation Wang Jiong; it seems especially important in light of Lukashenka’s planned visit to China in September.
Lukashenka: Only lazy people don
Lukashenka: Only lazy people don't earn well in Belarus
All the conditions for everyone to be able to earn a decent salary have been enabled in Belarus, however, it is necessary to make some effort to get the money, assumes the president.
Leanid Zlotnikau: The government knows what to do with the economy, but will do nothing
Leanid Zlotnikau: The government knows what to do with the economy, but will do nothing
Belarus is losing currency earnings – in the 6 months of 2016 the country earned 3 billion less than in the same period in 2015. Instead of removing the causes of the flop the state relies on magic.
Russia
Russia's Rosatom agreed to replace reactor vessel at Belarus NPP
State Corporation Rosatom has agreed to replace reactor vessel at the Astravets NPP in Belarus.
Gintautas Mažeikis: The relation of political field and arena in the framework of information war

In his report, philosopher Gintautas Mažeikis discusses several concepts that have been a part of the European social and philosophical thought for quite a time.

“It is our big joint work”

It is impossible to change life in cities just in three years (the timeline of the “Agenda 50” campaign implementation). But changing the structure of relationships in local communities is possible.

Shhh! Belarus Wants You to Think It’s Turning Over a New Leaf

Minsk’s muddled media clampdown could jeopardize warming of relations with the West.

Mikhail Matskevich: How to create a local agenda and make it a problem solving tool

To achieve changes, you need to be interested in them and stop pinning all hopes on the state.