Thursday 28 March 2024 | 21:39

The Financial Times: Can Europe’s last dictatorship avoid an economic meltdown?

20.03.2016  |  Politics   |  Dalibor Rohac, Martin Miszerak, The Financial Times,  
The Financial Times: Can Europe’s last dictatorship avoid an economic meltdown? Reuters V. Fedosenko

Today, it is clear that without deep economic reforms, Europe’s last autocratic regime cannot continue on that path, Dalibor Rohac, Martin Miszerak write in their paper.

Belarus has seen very little political change since gaining its independence in 1990, in spite of a warming in relations with the European Union (EU), which has recently ended visa bans and unfrozen the assets of 170 senior Belarusian officials. With the 12-year-old Mikalai Lukashenka being visibly groomed for a leadership role by his father, President Aliaksandr Lukashenka, Belarus remains Europe’s most bizarre political regime, steeped in Soviet nostalgia. Can it survive in today’s economic climate?

The enigmatic Belarusian economy, with its massive share of state ownership, finds itself in the midst of a deep crisis. Unlike Russia, which enjoys a stream of revenue from natural resources, there are few options left for Belarus but to move away from its state-dominated economy.

Belarus is closely integrated with Russia. In 2015, its GDP contracted by 3.5 per cent, while Russia’s contracted by 4.2 per cent. No recovery is in sight in either country. Katerina Bornukova, a research associate at BEROC, a Belarusian think tank, says Belarusia’s economy may contract by as much as 3 per cent this year.

The government has responded to the recession with restrictive monetary and fiscal policies, measures that were unavoidable given Belarus’s lack of foreign exchange reserves. “The country has tiny foreign currency reserves which in a perverse way is beneficial,” says Aliaksandr Chubrik, director of IPM Research Center, another think tank.

At the end of 2015, foreign currency reserves stood at approximately $4.2bn, enough to cover just six weeks’ worth of imports. This has forced the government into running a balanced budget and reducing its “directed lending,” which involves transfers from the central budget to state-owned banks for the purpose of further lending to state-owned enterprises (SOEs). Most of those are not profitable and in dire need of restructuring. The proportion of directed loans declined from over a quarter of all bank loans at the beginning of 2015 to just 16.2 per cent at the end of the year.

Whether they like it or not, the fall in directed lending is now forcing SOEs into restructuring. Lukashenka ordered them to cut costs by 25 per cent and to seek new export markets other than Russia. Belarusian trade with Russia, after all, is denominated in roubles and does not generate enough hard currency for the public budget.

Belarusian SOEs account for some 60 per cent of the country’s employment. “The risk is that a general collapse of SOEs might precipitate money printing by the central bank,” worries Chubrik.

Behind the crumbling façade of communist nostalgia, there is also a different face to the Belarusian economy. Take the Minsk-based Hi-Tech Park, for example. Established in 2005, the Park is essentially a tax-free zone and serves as a domicile for some 140 IT companies, many of which are completely foreign-owned. The core business of the Hi-Tech Park is software development for multinational clients throughout the world. The biggest company present is EPAM Systems, also listed on the New York Stock Exchange.

The Hi-Tech Park has also spawned such phenomena as the smartphone application Viber, started in 2010 by Israeli and Belarusian entrepreneurs, as well as the online game developer Wargaming.net, founded in 1998 by Belarusian entrepreneur Victor Kislov, who was recently added by Bloomberg to its list of the world’s billionaires.

While foreign direct investment has not played a major role in the Belarusian economy (in 2015, net FDI inflows were negative), two out of the three Belarusian wireless operators are now majority-owned by a Turkish and an Austrian investor, respectively. The government is also trying to attract a foreign strategic investor for its third operator.

Among privately owned Belarusian banks, foreign ownership dominates, too. And it is not just, as one would expect, the big Russian players – the Austrian Raiffeisen Bank and the Polish IDEA Bank have a strong presence. There is a bank privatisation programme underway, under the auspices of the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development. The share of private bank ownership would receive a major boost if Belinvestbank – the main object of the EBRD-assisted initiative – is indeed turned over to private hands.

But make no mistake: “A great deal remains to be done in Belarus in the area of structural reforms, particularly privatisation,” emphasises Daniel Krutzinna, a German national and member of the supervisory board of the Belarus Development Bank.

“The biggest headwind for the country,” Krutzinna says, “is the SOE sector, where reforms have only just started.” Even if complete privatisation remains elusive, the government can improve the governance of SOEs by enhancing management autonomy and incentives to restructure and find new markets. In many cases, it is also possible to recruit management talent from other post-communist countries, which have seen successful restructuring of their SOE sectors.

Finally, the government is examining other privatisation methods than just sales to strategic foreign investors. The Polish model of “employee leasing” (basically an instalment sale to an employee-management owned subsidiary), or the Czech “voucher privatisation” system could be among the options.

Back in the 1990s, Lukashenka forcefully rejected market reforms embraced by other post-communist economies and instead placed his country on a path that combined autocratic government with a dominant state ownership of the economy. Today, it is clear that without deep reforms, Europe’s hermit kingdom cannot continue on that path. It remains an open question whether the Lukashenka dynasty can pull off the necessary economic reforms without opening the country up politically as well – and losing its hold on power.

Other news section «Politics»

Andrei Yahorau — Al Jazeera: “Lukashenko is irresponsible”
Andrei Yahorau — Al Jazeera: “Lukashenko is irresponsible”
He said Belarus would likely face economic tightening not only as a result of the coronavirus pandemic but also a Russian trade oil crisis that worsened this past winter.
Shhh! Belarus Wants You to Think It’s Turning Over a New Leaf
Shhh! Belarus Wants You to Think It’s Turning Over a New Leaf
Minsk’s muddled media clampdown could jeopardize warming of relations with the West.
Statement of the BNP in connection with the wave of searches in the editorial offices of the Belarus
Statement of the BNP in connection with the wave of searches in the editorial offices of the Belarus
The Belarusan National Platform of the EaP CSF issued a statement in connection with the wave of searches in the editorial offices of the Belarusan media and the detention of journalists.
Statement of the Belarusan EaP CSF National Platform on solidarity with the civil society of Armenia
Statement of the Belarusan EaP CSF National Platform on solidarity with the civil society of Armenia
The Belarusan National Platform of the Eastern Partnership Civil Society Forum issued a statement on solidarity with the civil society of Armenia.
"Vilnius Consultations": Key points and recommendations on the future of EU Eastern Partnership
"Vilnius Consultations": Key points and recommendations on the future of EU Eastern Partnership
On September 11, the inaugural „Vilnius Consultations“ conference was organized by Vilnius Institute for Policy Analysis and Lithuanian Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
From farewell to a new Eastern policy and towards a new development
From farewell to a new Eastern policy and towards a new development
Poland and Germany were both initiators and drivers of a New Eastern policy linked to the Eastern neighborhood and Russia/Soviet Union.
Uladzimir Matskevich: The sooner the "Union State" is denounced, the better for Belarus
Uladzimir Matskevich: The sooner the "Union State" is denounced, the better for Belarus
Not only does the "Union State" undermine the establishment of civilized relations with Europe, but it hinders the possibility of normal relations between Belarus and Russia.
Uladzimir Matskevich: The regime can no longer control the situation in the country
Uladzimir Matskevich: The regime can no longer control the situation in the country
The authorities are unable to prolong the social contract with the people: there is no way out of the social crisis.
Press release in connection with the dialogue in the format of the EU-Belarus Coordination Group
Press release in connection with the dialogue in the format of the EU-Belarus Coordination Group
Belarusan National Platform of the EaP CSF welcomes the dialogue process in the format of the EU-Belarus Coordination Group, the third round of which was held in Minsk on 3-4 April 2017.
Statement of the BNP in connection with the events of March 25-26, 2017 in Minsk and other Belarusan
Statement of the BNP in connection with the events of March 25-26, 2017 in Minsk and other Belarusan
Belarusan National Platform of the EaP CSF issued a statement in connection with the events of March 25-26, 2017 in Minsk and other Belarusan cities.
Statement by the Eastern Partnership Civil Society Forum on mass repressions in Belarus
Statement by the Eastern Partnership Civil Society Forum on mass repressions in Belarus
The EaP CSF Steering Committee issued a statement on repressions against civil society activists and journalists in Belarus, in view of the demonstrations planned on 25 March 2017.
Uladzimir Matskevich: Belarus-Ukraine relations need to be re-established
Uladzimir Matskevich: Belarus-Ukraine relations need to be re-established
"Case of Zhadan" demonstrated that Belarus does not actually have a clear policy - neither domestic nor foreign.
Belarus
Belarus's Lukashenko alleges “fifth column” plot as unrest continues
Belarusan President Lukashenko said on Tuesday a “fifth column” was plotting to overthrow him with the help of foreign-backed fighters, days before a planned street protest in Minsk against a new tax.
In Belarus, a rising fear: Will we be the next Ukraine?
In Belarus, a rising fear: Will we be the next Ukraine?
The relationship between Russia and Belarus has never been an easy one.
Andrei Yahorau: European window of opportunity is slowly closing, relations take form of fatigue
Andrei Yahorau: European window of opportunity is slowly closing, relations take form of fatigue
The Belarusian regime is not able to pursue a truly multi-vector policy, and the EU cannot decide what it needs in the region on the whole and from Belarus in particular.
Uladzimir Matskevich: Today Belarus is in a very difficult situation
Uladzimir Matskevich: Today Belarus is in a very difficult situation
But even under the circumstances the authorities have various ways out.
Uladzimir Matskevich: Lukashenka does not disrupt Russian plans to annex Belarus
Uladzimir Matskevich: Lukashenka does not disrupt Russian plans to annex Belarus
But Lukashenka is afraid for his fate and position - he needs Belarus to be sovereign to fully exercise his power.
Andrei Yeliseyeu: Russia is taking drastic unconstructive steps  
Andrei Yeliseyeu: Russia is taking drastic unconstructive steps  
There should be no actual passport control for the Belarusians arriving in Russia within the framework of the existing Belarusian-Russian agreements.
Uladzimir Matskevich: Visa-free regime is not a political concession to the West
Uladzimir Matskevich: Visa-free regime is not a political concession to the West
It is a process of normalization of Belarus-EU relations. Belarus just fulfils its international commitments.
Andrei Yahorau: Belarusian regime is self-improving, the only threat so far is the economy crisis
Andrei Yahorau: Belarusian regime is self-improving, the only threat so far is the economy crisis
Political analyst emphasizes that Belarus is the first modern authoritarianism in the European space, a phenomenon not yet studied by anyone.
Gintautas Mažeikis: The relation of political field and arena in the framework of information war

In his report, philosopher Gintautas Mažeikis discusses several concepts that have been a part of the European social and philosophical thought for quite a time.

“It is our big joint work”

It is impossible to change life in cities just in three years (the timeline of the “Agenda 50” campaign implementation). But changing the structure of relationships in local communities is possible.

Shhh! Belarus Wants You to Think It’s Turning Over a New Leaf

Minsk’s muddled media clampdown could jeopardize warming of relations with the West.

Mikhail Matskevich: How to create a local agenda and make it a problem solving tool

To achieve changes, you need to be interested in them and stop pinning all hopes on the state.