Sunday 23 November 2014 | 09:55

Elena Tonkacheva: Anti-terrorist Concept doesn’t have any implementation parameters

05.08.2013  |  Society   |  Zmicier Kazlouski, EuroBelarus
Elena Tonkacheva: Anti-terrorist Concept  doesn’t have any implementation parameters

Without cooperation with the civil society it will be difficult for the state to implement recently adopted Anti-terrorist Concept.

Such an opinion in the talk with the EuroBelarus Information Service shared Elena Tonkacheva, human rights activist and the head of the Legal Transformation Centre “Lawtrend”.

Anti-terrorist Concept  was adopted by the Council of Ministers’ decision No. 658 after July 25 and put on the National Data Portal.

Elena Tonkacheva said that Legal Transformation Centre welcomes the adoption of this document and considers it to be an important step in treating terrorism by means of legal principles on the part of the state.

However, the expert also recalled that any concept should be supported by certain implementation parameters: “In this document I haven’t found the answers to the following questions: what will the success indicator be? In what way will monitoring and evaluation as well as concrete actions, necessary to implement the Concept, be carried out? Who is going to be responsible for that?” – wonders Elena Tonkacheva.

It’s not only about evaluation

The Concept has an interesting thesis, which says that the inner source of terroristic threat can be “relaxation of patriotism and traditional moral values among youths” for a variety of listed reasons. In this connection Elena Tonkacheva suggested to not only give evaluation of the Belarusan civil society development, but also pay attention to how Belarusan state resolves this situation.

“At post-Soviet area many states realize the role and the importance of the civil society and admit that strong civil society furthers the development of the country, overcoming inner barriers and tensions, integration of socially vulnerable groups. That is why such countries adopt the Concepts aimed at the strengthening of the civil society”, - recalled the expert.

Patronage of the untalented and weakening of the active

“In Belarus the situation is absolutely opposite. On the one hand, we have a number of public organizations under the state’s patronage, incapable to relieve social tension; on the other hand, we see the whole set of civil society actors, which have visible difficulties in their relationship and build-up of positive communication with the state bodies”, - admits Elena Tonkacheva.

The head of the Legal Transformation Centre emphasized that the fact that Belarusan authorities don’t show any willingness to cooperate with the part of civil society they cannot control is, perhaps, what weakens civil society. “And when stating the weakness of the civil society in the Concept, the state has to give realistic assessment about the steps it should take in order to provide good basic conditions for the citizens’ activity and the development of NGOs. I believe that here is where the potential to common development lies”.

We shouldn’t give immediate negative reaction

In order to implement the Concept successfully, we need to review the politics towards civil society, believes the head of the Lawtrend: “I stand for cooperation on condition that there is mutual understanding, respect and dialog between the state and the civil society”.

However, can it happen so that the adopted Concept will become an instrument of struggle against the civil society?

According to Elena Tonkacheva, it is difficult to give a well-grounded answer now. “Everything will depend on the application of the Concept, and only after some time passes – a year or two – we will be able to give a well-reasoned evaluation”, - assumes the expert. 

Other news section «Society»

Resolution on the support of Elena Tonkacheva is adopted in Batumi
Resolution on the support of Elena Tonkacheva is adopted in Batumi
The participants of the 6th CS Forum of the EaP that is taking place on November 20-21 in Batumi unanimously voted for the resolution “On the support of the human rights defendant Elena Tonkacheva”.
Point of view: Belarusan society is not ready to revise Belarus’ role in the Soviet era
Point of view: Belarusan society is not ready to revise Belarus’ role in the Soviet era
Justifying the origins of Belarus’ statehood, official Minsk repeatedly refers to Soviet ideology but alters its interpretation, stressing how Soviets contributed to Belarus’ independence.
Andrei Yahorau: EaP Civil Society Forum in Batumi either brings reforms or becomes formalization
Andrei Yahorau: EaP Civil Society Forum in Batumi either brings reforms or becomes formalization
The sixth meeting of the EaP CSF that is to take place on November 20-21 in Batumi will certainly be more lively and dynamic that the two previous ones.
Eastern Partnership Civil Society Forum: retrospective review for the future
Eastern Partnership Civil Society Forum: retrospective review for the future
The annual assembly in Batumi is a chance for the EaP and EU civil society to assess the situation in the region and formulate priorities for common agenda for reforms of the EaP countries.
Siarhei Drazdouski: The authorities don’t like well-reasoned stance of human rights fighters
Siarhei Drazdouski: The authorities don’t like well-reasoned stance of human rights fighters
Principled and well-reasoned stance of the human rights defendant Elena Tonkacheva could serve as a ground for her deportation from Belarus.
Sergei Krivenko: Russia President knows about Tonkacheva’s deportation but gives no reaction
Sergei Krivenko: Russia President knows about Tonkacheva’s deportation but gives no reaction
However, the reaction might be diverse. It would be a good thing if human rights defendants or activists with Belarusan citizenship were not deported from Russia in response.
Belarusan women are banned from 181 occupations; Lukashenka’s government says this is progress
Belarusan women are banned from 181 occupations; Lukashenka’s government says this is progress
This policy clearly reveals the state’s desire to control the choices of its citizens in social sphere; in this case, to manoeuvre women into prioritizing their reproductive role over all others.
New project will enable the disabled to act with unlimited possibilities
New project will enable the disabled to act with unlimited possibilities
The program of the Office for the rights of persons with disabilities and School of leaders was created only a year ago, but its members already organized several projects aimed at assisting PWDs.
The visit of Magna Charta Universitatum delegation to Minsk
The visit of Magna Charta Universitatum delegation to Minsk
At the meeting members of the Observatory Council presented potential applications of the Magna Charta Universitatum to foster Belarus’ integration into the international system of higher education.
Ulad Vialichka: “Belaya Rus” speculates about the term “civil society”
Ulad Vialichka: “Belaya Rus” speculates about the term “civil society”
The leader of the public organization Aliaksandr Radzkou stated that it is his organization that is involved in consolidation of Belarusan civil society; but representatives of civil society disagree.
Among all post-Soviet states only Belarus voiced claim to Russian in its national language policy
Among all post-Soviet states only Belarus voiced claim to Russian in its national language policy
The linguistic repertoire of the Belarusian society should be viewed in the post-colonial context, in which the inherent purity and originality of culture is untenable.
Andrei Yahorau: The West should honestly and clearly present its position on Tonkacheva’s case
Andrei Yahorau: The West should honestly and clearly present its position on Tonkacheva’s case
Separate appeals and statements won’t be able to influence the situation; but common efforts can.
Sharing experience: We have to employ persons with disabilities in business
Sharing experience: We have to employ persons with disabilities in business
It is stereotypes that prevent disabled from employment though sometimes applicants aren’t ready to work on the schedule. We should gather experts from different social spheres and look for solutions.
Enira Bronitskaja: I hope that civic society is able to help Elena Tonkacheva
Enira Bronitskaja: I hope that civic society is able to help Elena Tonkacheva
There are different ways to keep the famous human rights defendant in Belarus; what is important is not to give up.
Belarus outranks post-Soviet countries in human development index
Belarus outranks post-Soviet countries in human development index
However, it appears that Belarus improved its characteristics largely by prolonging the time its population spends in school rather than boosting population health and the standard of living indices.
Uladzimir Dunaeu: Will the Ministry of Information get the European point?
Uladzimir Dunaeu: Will the Ministry of Information get the European point?
Visitors from the Magna Charta Universitatum Observatory made a quiet and subtle trip to Belarus.
Despite bigger citizens’ awareness of CSOs, the ability to draw funding and people remains poor
Despite bigger citizens’ awareness of CSOs, the ability to draw funding and people remains poor
Following polling memo written by PACT, BelarusDigest issues overview of interrelations between Belarusans and civil society organisations.
Elena Tonkacheva: Fears of human rights defenders about the law on alternative service came true
Elena Tonkacheva: Fears of human rights defenders about the law on alternative service came true
Neglect of demands and suggestions introduced by the civil society led to the appropriate results, assumes Elena Tonkacheva, the head of the Legal Transformation Center “Lawtrend”.
PACT developed polling memo on awareness of civil society among Belarusan citizens
PACT developed polling memo on awareness of civil society among Belarusan citizens
This memo was prepared on the basis of September 2012-2014 polling data collected by the Independent Institute of Socio-Economic and Political Research (IISEPS).
Yaraslau Bekish: By deporting Tonkacheva the state might want to demoralize the whole third sector
Yaraslau Bekish: By deporting Tonkacheva the state might want to demoralize the whole third sector
Resolving the issue with Elena Tonkacheva’s deportation the authorities have not only satisfied their own needs for personal revenge but also tried to demoralize the whole third sector.
Solidarity with Belarus Information Office issues policy paper on Belarusian public sector

The study is a comprehensive overview of Belarusan public sector employees based on 12 focus groups held in Minsk and regions at the request of SBIO in 2014.

Tatiana Vadalazhskaya: We see the hunger for intellectual work

Having summarized the results of the “admission campaign”, the organizers were pleasantly amazed at the number of people who showed interest in the Flying University proposals in the new school season

Uladzimir Matskevich: Valeriya Novodvorskaya was a bone in the throat of Russian imperialists

For whom did Novodvorskaya present an obstacle? Why she was a lone soldier and didn’t demand heroism from others? And how did the “city madwoman” manage to change our way of thinking?