Thursday 28 May 2015 | 10:38

Elena Tonkacheva: Anti-terrorist Concept doesn’t have any implementation parameters

05.08.2013  |  Society   |  Zmicier Kazlouski, EuroBelarus,  
Elena Tonkacheva: Anti-terrorist Concept  doesn’t have any implementation parameters

Without cooperation with the civil society it will be difficult for the state to implement recently adopted Anti-terrorist Concept.

Such an opinion in the talk with the EuroBelarus Information Service shared Elena Tonkacheva, human rights activist and the head of the Legal Transformation Centre “Lawtrend”.

Anti-terrorist Concept  was adopted by the Council of Ministers’ decision No. 658 after July 25 and put on the National Data Portal.

Elena Tonkacheva said that Legal Transformation Centre welcomes the adoption of this document and considers it to be an important step in treating terrorism by means of legal principles on the part of the state.

However, the expert also recalled that any concept should be supported by certain implementation parameters: “In this document I haven’t found the answers to the following questions: what will the success indicator be? In what way will monitoring and evaluation as well as concrete actions, necessary to implement the Concept, be carried out? Who is going to be responsible for that?” – wonders Elena Tonkacheva.

It’s not only about evaluation

The Concept has an interesting thesis, which says that the inner source of terroristic threat can be “relaxation of patriotism and traditional moral values among youths” for a variety of listed reasons. In this connection Elena Tonkacheva suggested to not only give evaluation of the Belarusan civil society development, but also pay attention to how Belarusan state resolves this situation.

“At post-Soviet area many states realize the role and the importance of the civil society and admit that strong civil society furthers the development of the country, overcoming inner barriers and tensions, integration of socially vulnerable groups. That is why such countries adopt the Concepts aimed at the strengthening of the civil society”, - recalled the expert.

Patronage of the untalented and weakening of the active

“In Belarus the situation is absolutely opposite. On the one hand, we have a number of public organizations under the state’s patronage, incapable to relieve social tension; on the other hand, we see the whole set of civil society actors, which have visible difficulties in their relationship and build-up of positive communication with the state bodies”, - admits Elena Tonkacheva.

The head of the Legal Transformation Centre emphasized that the fact that Belarusan authorities don’t show any willingness to cooperate with the part of civil society they cannot control is, perhaps, what weakens civil society. “And when stating the weakness of the civil society in the Concept, the state has to give realistic assessment about the steps it should take in order to provide good basic conditions for the citizens’ activity and the development of NGOs. I believe that here is where the potential to common development lies”.

We shouldn’t give immediate negative reaction

In order to implement the Concept successfully, we need to review the politics towards civil society, believes the head of the Lawtrend: “I stand for cooperation on condition that there is mutual understanding, respect and dialog between the state and the civil society”.

However, can it happen so that the adopted Concept will become an instrument of struggle against the civil society?

According to Elena Tonkacheva, it is difficult to give a well-grounded answer now. “Everything will depend on the application of the Concept, and only after some time passes – a year or two – we will be able to give a well-reasoned evaluation”, - assumes the expert. 

Other news section «Society»

Experts: Forum of non-commercial law gives a chance to step away from disunity of CSOs
Experts: Forum of non-commercial law gives a chance to step away from disunity of CSOs
The participants of the first Belarusian Forum of non-commercial law relate their hopes with the map of legal reforms, though to realize the instrument a long-term work is needed.
Frontman of “Liapis Trubetskoy” and “Brutto” Siarhei Mihalok got Ukraine residence permit
Frontman of “Liapis Trubetskoy” and “Brutto” Siarhei Mihalok got Ukraine residence permit
Siarhei Mihalok and his producer, Anton Azizbekyan received the documents from the hands of the Head of the State Migration Service of Ukraine, Serhiy Radutny.
The principles of universal design and barrier-free environment were discussed in Minsk
The principles of universal design and barrier-free environment were discussed in Minsk
Social experiments, interactive games, mobile exhibitions and mobile apps – these are only few examples of using different tools helping to expand accessibility in different spheres.
“Vertical universities”
“Vertical universities”
What is the nature of legal sterility of Belarusan students’ consciousness and cowardice of their teachers? Why do the chiefs and governor’s servants occupy the councils of universities?
Second day of the first Belarusan Forum of non-commercial law (photos)
Second day of the first Belarusan Forum of non-commercial law (photos)
Among the prior goals of the Belarusan Forum in Lithuania is skill sharing of human rights defendants and leaders of NGOs, as well as discussion of common-European and international experience.
The first Belarusian Forum of non-commercial law started its work in Vilnius
The first Belarusian Forum of non-commercial law started its work in Vilnius
About a hundred lawyers and leaders of the biggest non-governmental organizations, as well as experts from Russia, Ukraine, and the EU countries are taking part in the work of the Forum.
Tickets to Titanic and an undermining under the non-existing building
Tickets to Titanic and an undermining under the non-existing building
A university should be post-classical and flexible, as while we will be building classical examples, new generation will turn to those, who promise success at employment market, believes the expert.
Mission of the National University was discussed in Minsk
Mission of the National University was discussed in Minsk
How the “Russian World” will help the Belarusan University join Oxford, Cambridge, or Sorbonne?
Bologna process: Official Minsk uses education sphere to reduce tension between Belarus and the EU
Bologna process: Official Minsk uses education sphere to reduce tension between Belarus and the EU
And that perfectly demonstrates to the Belarusan political opposition and civil society that the EU has no intentions of battling with a dictatorship in the heart of Europe in the near future.
NGOs are invited to the National Ecologic Forum
NGOs are invited to the National Ecologic Forum
The 13th National Ecology Forum will be dedicated to the ecologization of the Belarusian economy.
Andrei Yahorau: Belarus shouldn’t expect anything from the Summit in Riga
Andrei Yahorau: Belarus shouldn’t expect anything from the Summit in Riga
The expectations are limited to initialing of agreement in the sphere of visa regime simplification, signing of which is being hindered by a number of moot points.
Point of view: Belarus has an identity crisis
Point of view: Belarus has an identity crisis
In the end of the Soviet Union, Belarus was the most russified of all its republics with few supporters of national revival among Communist leaders. Still, a small nationalist tendency was present.
Harry Pahaniaila: Amnesty of political prisoners in Belarus is rather an exception to the rule
Harry Pahaniaila: Amnesty of political prisoners in Belarus is rather an exception to the rule
The cases of political prisoners are, as usually, very thoroughly considered by administrations of penitentiary institutions in such a way so that the figurants would never be amnestied.
Andrei Rolenok: Despite political risks, the National University should be established in Belarus
Andrei Rolenok: Despite political risks, the National University should be established in Belarus
Only in this case the university will be able to lay claims to being an alternative to the EHU; thus, the already existing initiatives should unite to form a strong institution.
Belarus joins Bologna Process at the second attempt
Belarus joins Bologna Process at the second attempt
The question of Belarus’ admittance to the European Higher Education Area and joining the Bologna Process was discussed during the Ninth Bologna Process Ministerial Conference in Yerevan.
Elena Tonkacheva: Law on alternative service is adopted. It’s time to start amending it
Elena Tonkacheva: Law on alternative service is adopted. It’s time to start amending it
The content of the law adopted in second reading made the fears voiced by human rights defendants earlier real, notes the head of the Center for Legal Transformation “Lawtrend”.
Aliaksei Kryvalap: National University can’t be established from nothing
Aliaksei Kryvalap: National University can’t be established from nothing
Belarus has been dreaming about the main university of the nation since 1991. But where should we look for its origins – in Vilnius of the 16th century or in partisan dugout of 1994?
Human trafficking in Belarus and Ukraine: An underscored problem
Human trafficking in Belarus and Ukraine: An underscored problem
Despite the noteworthy number of men exposed to trafficking, so far trafficking in these Eastern-European countries was underscored.
UPR procedure is the 1st time we saw selective cooperation of Belarus with the UN in public
UPR procedure is the 1st time we saw selective cooperation of Belarus with the UN in public
Human rights defendant Valiantsin Stefanovich believes it is worth reminding the Ministry of Justice about the position of the UNHRC regarding the non-registration of the HRC "Viasna".
Bruce Bucknell: Accessibility is more an issue of will than resources
Bruce Bucknell: Accessibility is more an issue of will than resources
Accessibility is not only a physical issue, but also a mental one, the issue of stereotypes existing in the society, said the British ambassador to Belarus when opening Accessibility Week in Minsk.
Research into Belarusan organized civil society’s solidarity potential

We present a research results report of the Belarusan organized civil society’s solidarity potential.

Tatiana Vadalazhskaya: We see the hunger for intellectual work

Having summarized the results of the “admission campaign”, the organizers were pleasantly amazed at the number of people who showed interest in the Flying University proposals in the new school season

Uladzimir Matskevich: Valeriya Novodvorskaya was a bone in the throat of Russian imperialists

For whom did Novodvorskaya present an obstacle? Why she was a lone soldier and didn’t demand heroism from others? And how did the “city madwoman” manage to change our way of thinking?