Thursday 28 March 2024 | 11:01

Antonella Valmorbida: Cooperation with civil society to promote public administration reform in EaP

09.09.2016  |  Society   |  alda-europe.eu,  
Antonella Valmorbida: Cooperation with civil society to promote public administration reform in EaP

In this paper, Secretary General of ALDA (The European Association for Local Democracy) writes on reform in public administration and decentralization in the Eastern Partnership countries.

Objectives of the paper:

1. To raise awareness and knowledge on the possibilities and importance of working together with civil society organisations (CSOs) as key stakeholders to support Public Administration reform and decentralisation, in EaP

2. To present the key points as for PAR from the point of view of CSOs

3. To present good practices of CSOs cooperating to support Public Administration Reform and Decentralisation

i. Context/importance of PAR in the Neighborhoud. The role of Public Administration Reform and Decentralisation/strengthening local government in Neighborhoud

PAR and Decentralisation represent crucial and cross-cutting elements among the objectives of the Neighborhoud policy and in the EaP. They affect systemically the governance of the State, its functioning, its capacity to deliver service as well as its relationship with citizens. PAR is a fundamental bone of a well functioning democratic State. The European Neighborhoud Policy aims at engaging in a privileged relationship and at creating special conditions for a better and more efficient cooperation. ENPI and EaP represent an enhanced set of objectives for a progressive economic integration between the EU and the partner countries. It needs to create homogeneous ways of working that will make easier cooperating and living in proximity. The Acquis Communautaire of the Enlargement are here represented by key elements based on values and systems of governance: transparency, accountability, effectiveness of policies, democratic representation, and fight against corruption. Final beneficiaries are citizens and development of businesses for a global and fair, shared welfare.

ii. Why working with Civil Society in promoting Public Administration Reform

a) The reform of Public Administration is NOT an essentially legislative process but it is strictly connected with cultural and systemic elements in the community. It is therefore essential to consider the existence/non existence of the relation between institutions and citizens. PAR and the legislation cannot be developed without considering a constant process of information, dialogue and exchanges with citizens that will establish trust from both sides that will then allow the laws/provisions to have a certain chance of being implemented.

b) The reform of the Public Administration and the processes of decentralisation address the organisation of powers, responsibilities and competences. The processes are participated by two essential parties: institutions and citizens. Both need to go through their own process of capacity building, training and development. If we implement training for local authorities (politicians and civil servants), the same should be done for citizens and CSOs. The improvement should address both the sides of the governance & institutions, and civil society.

c) These two components of the governance (CSOs&citizens and public institutions) CANNOT develop and improve in parallel paths without never meeting and crossing each other. They have to develop thanks to joint, cooperative processes. Their developed capacities should be built together in a constant exchange and dialogue. Having a perfect legislative system and then start working on citizenship and governance cannot be the goal!

d) Participation of policy makers (local and national) is not a process that follows one point after the other, rule by rule, but should actually be an “attitude” towards participative governance. This attitude should frame the whole approach. Some very effective and innovative way of participatory democracy come actually from less democratic states with new ideas for matching a big divide between citizens and authorities.

e) Generally speaking, there is a global problem as for the recognition of the importance of laws and regulations. The legislative processes exist and sometimes can also be very good (i.e. the different legislative provisions existing in the Armenian law as for citizens participation), but the problem lies within its implementation and in the fact that, culturally speaking, there is a gap between legislation and real perception and recognition of its value.

f) Why to focus on Neighborhoud. The Neighborhoud policy raised objectives since it aims at building systems that are more homogenous with Europe in terms of value and governance (labour, public and private, governance).

iii. Common issues at stake and highlights by civil society in the Neighborhoud

From the point of view of civil society groups active in Public Administration Reform programmes, several are the issues at stake.

a) Improvement of Civil Service: In all the countries concerned, civil service represents an issue at stake. The targets in this case are a) de-politicising the civil service b) creating effective conditions of working c) creating systemic efficiency and liaison with the political and administrative body d) reducing possibilities of corruption e) developing competences & capacities of civil servants to implement their work

b) Decentralisation and strengthened competences of local governments, local democracy, fiscal decentralisation for a more efficient functioning of local governments. In all the countries concerned (in particular in the Eastern partnership countries), municipalities and local bodies are still extremely weak and cannot fully implement their expected role. For most of them, there is only one source for funding from the transfer from the State. Some of the Local governments have hardly resources for a minimum functioning and they cannot represent a real centre of decision-making.

c) Lack of participative approach. Legislation on citizens’ participation for policy making (including the element of Public Administrative reforms) differs country by country. Some are more advanced but they globally lack practices and implementation. The legal provisions miss spaces for dialogue and engagement with citizens and CSOs. The gap between institutions and civil society is big and needs to be bridged over.

d) Lack of transparency and corruption. Public institutions (national and local) are heavily affected by corruption, which is preventing a virtuous growth in democratic, social and economic terms. Public administration reform should address the problem of corruption, which is cultural and systemic.

iv. Added value of civil society in Public Administration Reform

a) CSOs as key stakeholders of community: Public Administration Reforms should engage in a systemic change all the stakeholders of the community. PAR is a cross cutting process, with public and private actors. Civil society organisations represent key stakeholders of community development. CSOs can mobilize general attention and public awareness on the importance to have good governance and accountable, reliable institutions.

Case box:

**The Local Democracy Agency in Armenia is engaged in a set of simple and very accessible courses on local democracy and local governance in the high schools of Gyumri/Shirak region. The students learn the basic elements of local governance as provided by the European Charter on Local Self Government of the Council of Europe. **

b) CSOs can inform and engage citizens in collecting information and opinions while the process of reform is ongoing, and can help disseminating and implementing legislative provisions. They can naturally become partners of the PAR reform as a go-between the institutions and the citizens.

Case box:

**In Ukraine – the Local Democracy Agency in Dnipro is implementing a series of local seminars to explain to citizens the impact and rules of the territorial reforms in Ukraine. They provide very direct and easy to get information on important processes for the rest of the Country. The Oblast of Dnipropetrovsk is partnering with local civil society group3.

**In Belarus, the role of civil society is particularly important. It is organised mainly through the National Platform of the Civil Society Forum for Eastern Partnership. In this country, the human potential of local authorities is non sufficient. Despite the difficulties, in some case, we have seen the creation of CSOs expert councils, i.e. independent grousp of citizens aimed at solving specific problems at the local level. These have been established in particular linked to social and cultural activities, protection of environment, youth and health. **

c) CSOs working together with public institutions are able to work at the cultural level of the issue and they build trust thanks to a process of awareness of shared problem solving. By having direct contacts, elected representatives can meet and work with citizens and CSOs and engage on a dialogue, which will benefit the entire community.

Case box:

In Georgia, the Association of Municipalities of Georgia (NALAG) has developed a two years programme on mobilizing citizens for local democracy. They have addressed and trained local community leaders to build a constructive dialogue with local authorities. Thousands of people have been trained by this project in Georgia, thus substantially increasing the understanding of the role of local authorities in the country.

The programme LADDER of ALDA is creating a vast platform of awareness-raising, by making local authorities and CSOs work together on global citizenship issues and shared responsibilities.

c) CSOs can work on a participative processes and attitude of elaboration of public policies, both at the local level and at the national level. The added value of the participative processes is the possible identification of best solutions to give problems and the mediation of critical interests.

Case box:

In Armenia, the city of Dilijan has funded and supported some local initiatives proposed though consultations with citizens. The process was participative and engaged the public institutions and local CSOs.

The Subgroup on Local Government and PAR of the CSF EaP has produced a report on Citizen Participation in EaP (2012) (attached) highlighting the different possible documents to refer to: the European Charter on Local Government of the Council of Europe and its additional protocol on Citizens participation 5 and the Code on Good practices for Citizens participation of the Conference of the INGOs of the Council of Europe6 .

*** In Ukraine, two important civil society platforms were created to support these processes: “The reanimation pack of reform” and the “New country”. The experts of these platforms have influenced the content of the reforms in the Parliament and governments. There is a quite effective commission of dialogue between the experts of CSOs and institutions. The National platform of the Civil Society Forum for Eastern Partnership is effectively included in this dialogue with institutions. Even the Public Service reform is among the good success of this cooperation. Within the National Agency dealing with questions of civil service, a Consultative Council was created, where the CSOs were particularly active in identifying legislative steps. Now even the monitoring of this reform is composed of a group on CSOs representatives.

d) Building the process of working together for a community approach to development. A joint process in identifying solution (CSOs and public institutions, at the local and national level) creates the best conditions for addressing problems in such difficult conditions as we often meet in many of the countries the Neighborhoud. The awareness process for citizens is improving the sense of common responsibility for public affairs, and opening a dialogue with public institutions

Case box:

In Belarus, several regranting activities joining efforts of local institutions and CSOs have been initiated by the Lev Saphieh Foundation and its citizens’ centers, and ALDA. The programme is supported by ALDA and the European Commission - Project Tandem II (rehabilitation of a play ground for sport, cycling path for sustainable tourism, cultural heritage, etc.)

iv. Recommendations for improvement of PAR and involvement of CSOs

From the Civil society point of view, the following steps and priorities are proposed in order to increase the impact of our common work in promoting Public Administration Reform in the Neighborhoud.

a) To increase support to decentralisation and strengthening of local authorities, local democracy, including fiscal decentralisation. The legislation must provide the norms defining the status of municipalities. They must be provided with sustainable financial sources so that they can carry out their responsibilities, and possibilities of the application of shared taxes system must be considered by making changes to the legislation

b) To work on capacity and awareness of both local authorities (elected official and civil servants) and civil society on the role and importance of local governance and possibility to work together

c) To move for the ratification, alignment and implementation of the principles of the European charter on Local Self government and the use of the principles and instruments proposed by the Code of Good practice for civil participation in decision-making processes of the Council of Europe

d) To focus on Local democracy – understood as decentralisation of powers, competences and responsibilities, entailing elections at the local level as well as the development of the concept of the local community, accountability, transparency, cooperation between public stakeholders and civil society

e) To focus and strengthening the capacity building for associations of local authorities and the network of networks of civil society, that working together have a broad national impact.

f) Introduction of systems of efficiency for public service delivery, in cooperation with civil society organisations

g) To increase the participation of civil society in the decision making process at the local and national level with full implementation of the existing legislation and identification of more possibilities

h) To define the spheres and/or direction or level of reform where the resources of local and international CSO’s will be used effectively

i) To ensure inclusiveness of CSO’s in the process of planning implementation of Public Administration reform and the Law on State Service

j) To develop and implement effective mechanisms of permanent institutional dialogue between Government, Parliament, the central authorities on the one hand, and representatives of local public administration, civil society, experts in the field, on the other hand.

k) To focus and strengthen common activities (planning, elaborating processes and implementation) between CSOs and public institutions. Working together is probably the best way to develop an effective PAR.

l) To Focus on micro support for working together. Re-granting schemes could be a good opportunity to disseminate initiatives of cooperation and awareness raising throughout the country and being able to reach the remote provinces.

You can read the full article at www.alda-europe.eu

Other news section «Society»

What actually the State List of Historical and Cultural Values gives to Belarusan Heritage Sites?
What actually the State List of Historical and Cultural Values gives to Belarusan Heritage Sites?
The Belarus Committee of ICOMOS announces the collection of cases on the effectiveness of the State List of Historical and Cultural Values as a tool of the safeguarding the cultural monuments.
The right to heritage according to the standards of the Faro Convention: is it possible in Belarus?
The right to heritage according to the standards of the Faro Convention: is it possible in Belarus?
On March 27-28, the Belarus ICOMOS and the EuroBelarus held an online expert workshop on expanding opportunities for community participation in the governance of historical and cultural heritage.
“It is our big joint work”
“It is our big joint work”
It is impossible to change life in cities just in three years (the timeline of the “Agenda 50” campaign implementation). But changing the structure of relationships in local communities is possible.
The “Agenda 50” campaign was finalised by the Regional Development Forum
The “Agenda 50” campaign was finalised by the Regional Development Forum
The Forum was devoted not so much to the outputs as to the challenges and prospects after the creation and signing of local agendas.
Mikhail Matskevich: How to create a local agenda and make it a problem solving tool
Mikhail Matskevich: How to create a local agenda and make it a problem solving tool
To achieve changes, you need to be interested in them and stop pinning all hopes on the state.
“If a person cannot leave the apartment, he or she does not need an accessible Opera House”
“If a person cannot leave the apartment, he or she does not need an accessible Opera House”
In Stoubcy, they talked about universal design and conducted pilot monitoring of two urban sites accessibility.
Local agenda in Valożyn: mission accomplished
Local agenda in Valożyn: mission accomplished
"Specificity is different, but the priority is general." In Valożyn, a local strategy for the implementation of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities was signed.
How Ščučyn was proceeding towards the solution of problems of people with disabilities
How Ščučyn was proceeding towards the solution of problems of people with disabilities
The campaign "Agenda 50" was summed up in Ščučyn, and a local action plan for the implementation of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities was signed there.
A program to improve the quality of life of people with disabilities was designed in Stolin
A program to improve the quality of life of people with disabilities was designed in Stolin
The regional center has become the second city in Belarus where the local plan for the implementation of the principles of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities was signed.
“Agenda 50” in Belarus: from strategies to implementation
“Agenda 50” in Belarus: from strategies to implementation
Representatives of the campaign “Agenda 50” from five pilot cities discussed achievements in creating local agendas for implementing the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities.
In Stoubcy, a local action plan for the implementation of the Convention was signed
In Stoubcy, a local action plan for the implementation of the Convention was signed
It is noteworthy that out of the five pilot cities, Stoubcy was the last to join the campaign “Agenda 50”, but the first one to complete the preparation of the local agenda.
The monitoring of accessibility was presented in Stolin
The monitoring of accessibility was presented in Stolin
On May 28, the city hosted a presentation of the results of the project "Equal to Equal" which was dedicated to monitoring the barrier-free environment in the city.
“They think if the legs don’t function, neither functions the head.”
“They think if the legs don’t function, neither functions the head.”
In Babruysk, wheelchair users are fighting discrimination.
The real work of the Convention depends on all interested communities and organizations
The real work of the Convention depends on all interested communities and organizations
What results has the campaign "Agenda 50" given, what helps to implement the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities in the regions?
The Convention is a fight against fears, barriers and stigmata
The Convention is a fight against fears, barriers and stigmata
Experts in Valožyn have determined that the quality of people’s life depends on their awareness.
The Convention should become a "living tool”, rather than remaining just an ordinary document
The Convention should become a "living tool”, rather than remaining just an ordinary document
On March 3, members of the campaign "Agenda 50" from different Belarusian cities met in Minsk. The campaign is aimed at the implementation of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities.
The main thing is one’s personal motivation for full active life (PHOTOS)
The main thing is one’s personal motivation for full active life (PHOTOS)
There are being implemented three projects under the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities campaign in the city of Babruysk.
One man does not make a team, but united we are able to do a lot
One man does not make a team, but united we are able to do a lot
In Ščučyn, people with disabilities learned to be leaders and to advocate their interests.
Barrier-free environment – it is not a ramp, but a means of independence (PHOTOS)
Barrier-free environment – it is not a ramp, but a means of independence (PHOTOS)
In Stolin, social organizations and local authorities are implementing a project aimed at independent living of persons with disabilities, and creating local agenda for the district.
Polish experts: We say “equality” and you say “inclusion”
Polish experts: We say “equality” and you say “inclusion”
Will creation of local agendas be an effective tool in ensuring rights of persons with disabilities in Belarus, just as it was in Poland?
Gintautas Mažeikis: The relation of political field and arena in the framework of information war

In his report, philosopher Gintautas Mažeikis discusses several concepts that have been a part of the European social and philosophical thought for quite a time.

“It is our big joint work”

It is impossible to change life in cities just in three years (the timeline of the “Agenda 50” campaign implementation). But changing the structure of relationships in local communities is possible.

Shhh! Belarus Wants You to Think It’s Turning Over a New Leaf

Minsk’s muddled media clampdown could jeopardize warming of relations with the West.

Mikhail Matskevich: How to create a local agenda and make it a problem solving tool

To achieve changes, you need to be interested in them and stop pinning all hopes on the state.