Friday 29 March 2024 | 08:45

Why do Belarusans misunderstand Ukrainians?

15.02.2016  |  Politics
Why do Belarusans misunderstand Ukrainians?

For days Belarusan intellectuals were discussing what can culture oppose to the “hatred machines” that are accompanying a war. They argued until they almost fought.

It didn’t, of course, ended in a physical fight; however, peacemakers were generously crushing each other with arguments and their personal experience. That was the beginning of the public campaign “Understanding Ukraine”, and in the current situation that Ukraine is in it looks quite symbolic. The “EuroBelarus” Information Service writes about the key points of the first round of the discussion.

On barricades and high culture

In general, the campaign is dedicated to the launch of the “Year of Ukrainian literature”; that’s why the moderator and one of the meeting’s guests, philosopher Ihar Babkou and the poet and translator Andrei Hadanovich brought some of their favorite Ukrainian books with them in order to leave them at the “Ukrainian library” of the Lohvinau book store. By the way, anyone can bring more books to the improvised library, as well as read them: one should only leave the employer of the bookstore his or her contacts to get the book home for several weeks.

The idea of the public campaign came as an answer to the Ukrainian situation of the recent years, which influenced the intellectual field. “Either you are on the barricades and bring shells in which case you should forget about yourself as a thinker, or you find a place and mission of culture in this situation of war,” – Ihar Babkou confounded everyone with a dilemma. He believes that literature and high culture are the best opposition to the war.

Andrei Hadanovich noticed that many Belarusan authors (including himself) first were publishing their books in Ukraine in Ukrainian language, and only after that – in Belarusian in his homeland, Belarus.

“Every Belarusan authors, who comes to Ukraine, gets the warmer and more abounding in enthusiasm, intrigues, and euphoria welcome than in Belarus, - he marks. – Being a poet in Ukraine is incomparably more thrilling than being a poet in Belarus.”

Belarusans are not perceived as something alien in Ukraine. Indeed, our nations can speak their own languages and still perfectly understand each other, since as linguists say, Belarusan and Ukrainian languages are only 17% different and 83% coincide. One the one hand, it seems that there’s no need to translate something that can be easily understood. However, the authors see a certain declaration of love in that. At the same time, today’s Ukrainians are ready to read in Belarusan and publishers are ready to launch books in Belarusan.

On the one hand, there is a certain stereotype of resemblance.

If to a certain degree we are Balto-Centric Slavs, Ukraine rather belongs to Balkans. Siarhei Zhadan is a Slavic Emir Kusturica. When you read for the Ukrainian public they laugh if they want to; if you read something in Belarus and try to laugh they try not to laugh as long as they can, but after the readings they approach you and thank for the hilarious time,” – Andrei Hadanovich said.

On antisemitism, nationalism, and dictatorship

Cultural scientist Julia Charniauskaja assumes that we have already created “our” Ukraine, adding something that we have expected from Russia, but what we didn’t get from it. “We constantly create Ukraine as some inspiring homeland, which we would like to have here,” – Julia Charniauskaja is convinced.

She noted that when she lived in Ukraine she felt that she is not perceived as “one of their kind” but rather as “the one of others”, whom they treat well. The cultural scientist recalled the Jewish pogroms in Ukraine, marking that antisemitism is more visible in Ukraine, as well as said that “it’s not worth white-washing the Ukrainian Insurgent Army, which is now happening in Ukraine”.

I had a feeling that all this got somehow became even in Lvov, whereas in Kyiv it has become aggravated,” – Julia Charniauskaja said, admitting that she hasn’t been to Ukraine for the long time.

“If we compare 2012-2013 and 2014-2015, over this time the acceptance of Russian language in the streets and in cafes has become much bigger than it used to be before,” – contradicted the philosopher and methodologist Uladzimir Matskevich.

According to him, now Ukrainian language in Kyiv ceased to be the passkey. Maidan was a certain initiation of the Ukrainian nation, a time when people crossed some border.

There is a phenomenon of mirroring propaganda. I understand that Russia is big, frightful, and mean. But on the other hand, the other side gives Russia the same treatment. Should the response be symmetrical?” – Julia Charniauskaja asked herself a question.

A dispute started: Uladzimir Matskevich tried to convince his opponent that Ukraine’s response is, indeed, non-symmetrical. He supported his statements with his own experience, admitting, however, that there are hotheads here.

“Show me at least one Ukrainian TV-channel that is similar to Russian. You wouldn’t find that”, - the philosopher marked.

Despite the efforts of Ihar Babkou to put the rails of the round table back to the work of authors, the heated debate fully absorbed the participants.

“I was born with the nickname “banderovec (“Banderivtsi” is a term derived from the name of Stepan Bandera; nowadays it usually refers to Ukrainian nationalists and is often used by the Russian propaganda in negative meaning as a synonym for banditry – EuroBelarus),” – continued Uladzimir Matskevich. – I lived in Siberia, where there’ve been a lot of resettlers. We, Belarusans, were all called “Banderivtsi”.

Matskevich marked that throughout his life he has never met everyday nationalism. Julia Charniauskaja contradicted, saying that she had repeatedly been in the situation when in response to the Russian language in Latvia people would show her the wrong direction.

Trying to get back to the primary idea of the campaign, Uladzimir Matskevich said that after Maidan thinking has basically disappeared in Ukraine.

The only thing that the interlocutors agreed on was that Belarus is much more European than Ukraine.

On degraded people and green light

Julia Charniauskaja recalled the idea of Mark Schaller about the opposition of absolutely pure and weak “spirit” and completely materialistic, though strong “impulse”.

As Ihar Babkou noted, the discussion has led to the participants’ distribution on the barricades re the situation no one of them actually knows well enough.

The fact that we don’t understand each other (Belarusans and Ukrainians – EuroBelarus) starts from non-understanding ourselves,” – summed up the philosopher and methodologist.

The most meaningless discussion among Belarusans is that about Ukraine and about Maidan, since when we start talking about it, the “hatred machine” is absorbing us, Ihar Babkou is convinced.

“We really don’t understand Ukrainians, - he concluded. – The state for Ukrainians is “today it’s one name, before that the name was different.” I feel as a German when I start talking to Ukrainians and explaining to them that the state starts from crossing the street to the green light”.

Well, Andrei Hadanovich is, obviously, right when saying that to remain human and stop hatred is the circle of reproduction of hatred in nature. However, one should at least try to understand his or her neighbor. Within the course of the campaign there will be lots of opportunities to do that: organizers promise discussions, movie sessions, book presentations, and meetings with the authors. Follow the announcements!

Other news section «Politics»

Andrei Yahorau — Al Jazeera: “Lukashenko is irresponsible”
Andrei Yahorau — Al Jazeera: “Lukashenko is irresponsible”
He said Belarus would likely face economic tightening not only as a result of the coronavirus pandemic but also a Russian trade oil crisis that worsened this past winter.
Shhh! Belarus Wants You to Think It’s Turning Over a New Leaf
Shhh! Belarus Wants You to Think It’s Turning Over a New Leaf
Minsk’s muddled media clampdown could jeopardize warming of relations with the West.
Statement of the BNP in connection with the wave of searches in the editorial offices of the Belarus
Statement of the BNP in connection with the wave of searches in the editorial offices of the Belarus
The Belarusan National Platform of the EaP CSF issued a statement in connection with the wave of searches in the editorial offices of the Belarusan media and the detention of journalists.
Statement of the Belarusan EaP CSF National Platform on solidarity with the civil society of Armenia
Statement of the Belarusan EaP CSF National Platform on solidarity with the civil society of Armenia
The Belarusan National Platform of the Eastern Partnership Civil Society Forum issued a statement on solidarity with the civil society of Armenia.
"Vilnius Consultations": Key points and recommendations on the future of EU Eastern Partnership
"Vilnius Consultations": Key points and recommendations on the future of EU Eastern Partnership
On September 11, the inaugural „Vilnius Consultations“ conference was organized by Vilnius Institute for Policy Analysis and Lithuanian Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
From farewell to a new Eastern policy and towards a new development
From farewell to a new Eastern policy and towards a new development
Poland and Germany were both initiators and drivers of a New Eastern policy linked to the Eastern neighborhood and Russia/Soviet Union.
Uladzimir Matskevich: The sooner the "Union State" is denounced, the better for Belarus
Uladzimir Matskevich: The sooner the "Union State" is denounced, the better for Belarus
Not only does the "Union State" undermine the establishment of civilized relations with Europe, but it hinders the possibility of normal relations between Belarus and Russia.
Uladzimir Matskevich: The regime can no longer control the situation in the country
Uladzimir Matskevich: The regime can no longer control the situation in the country
The authorities are unable to prolong the social contract with the people: there is no way out of the social crisis.
Press release in connection with the dialogue in the format of the EU-Belarus Coordination Group
Press release in connection with the dialogue in the format of the EU-Belarus Coordination Group
Belarusan National Platform of the EaP CSF welcomes the dialogue process in the format of the EU-Belarus Coordination Group, the third round of which was held in Minsk on 3-4 April 2017.
Statement of the BNP in connection with the events of March 25-26, 2017 in Minsk and other Belarusan
Statement of the BNP in connection with the events of March 25-26, 2017 in Minsk and other Belarusan
Belarusan National Platform of the EaP CSF issued a statement in connection with the events of March 25-26, 2017 in Minsk and other Belarusan cities.
Statement by the Eastern Partnership Civil Society Forum on mass repressions in Belarus
Statement by the Eastern Partnership Civil Society Forum on mass repressions in Belarus
The EaP CSF Steering Committee issued a statement on repressions against civil society activists and journalists in Belarus, in view of the demonstrations planned on 25 March 2017.
Uladzimir Matskevich: Belarus-Ukraine relations need to be re-established
Uladzimir Matskevich: Belarus-Ukraine relations need to be re-established
"Case of Zhadan" demonstrated that Belarus does not actually have a clear policy - neither domestic nor foreign.
Belarus
Belarus's Lukashenko alleges “fifth column” plot as unrest continues
Belarusan President Lukashenko said on Tuesday a “fifth column” was plotting to overthrow him with the help of foreign-backed fighters, days before a planned street protest in Minsk against a new tax.
In Belarus, a rising fear: Will we be the next Ukraine?
In Belarus, a rising fear: Will we be the next Ukraine?
The relationship between Russia and Belarus has never been an easy one.
Andrei Yahorau: European window of opportunity is slowly closing, relations take form of fatigue
Andrei Yahorau: European window of opportunity is slowly closing, relations take form of fatigue
The Belarusian regime is not able to pursue a truly multi-vector policy, and the EU cannot decide what it needs in the region on the whole and from Belarus in particular.
Uladzimir Matskevich: Today Belarus is in a very difficult situation
Uladzimir Matskevich: Today Belarus is in a very difficult situation
But even under the circumstances the authorities have various ways out.
Uladzimir Matskevich: Lukashenka does not disrupt Russian plans to annex Belarus
Uladzimir Matskevich: Lukashenka does not disrupt Russian plans to annex Belarus
But Lukashenka is afraid for his fate and position - he needs Belarus to be sovereign to fully exercise his power.
Andrei Yeliseyeu: Russia is taking drastic unconstructive steps  
Andrei Yeliseyeu: Russia is taking drastic unconstructive steps  
There should be no actual passport control for the Belarusians arriving in Russia within the framework of the existing Belarusian-Russian agreements.
Uladzimir Matskevich: Visa-free regime is not a political concession to the West
Uladzimir Matskevich: Visa-free regime is not a political concession to the West
It is a process of normalization of Belarus-EU relations. Belarus just fulfils its international commitments.
Andrei Yahorau: Belarusian regime is self-improving, the only threat so far is the economy crisis
Andrei Yahorau: Belarusian regime is self-improving, the only threat so far is the economy crisis
Political analyst emphasizes that Belarus is the first modern authoritarianism in the European space, a phenomenon not yet studied by anyone.
Gintautas Mažeikis: The relation of political field and arena in the framework of information war

In his report, philosopher Gintautas Mažeikis discusses several concepts that have been a part of the European social and philosophical thought for quite a time.

“It is our big joint work”

It is impossible to change life in cities just in three years (the timeline of the “Agenda 50” campaign implementation). But changing the structure of relationships in local communities is possible.

Shhh! Belarus Wants You to Think It’s Turning Over a New Leaf

Minsk’s muddled media clampdown could jeopardize warming of relations with the West.

Mikhail Matskevich: How to create a local agenda and make it a problem solving tool

To achieve changes, you need to be interested in them and stop pinning all hopes on the state.