Wednesday 22 February 2017 | 00:00

Andrei Bastunets: State propaganda isn’t able to withstand the Russian propaganda

11.05.2015  |  Society   |  Aliaksei Jurych,  EuroBelarus
Andrei Bastunets: State propaganda isn’t able to withstand the Russian propaganda

Even though the system of control over the information area created in Belarus can block the spreading of any information.

Lawyer Andrei Bastunets was elected new head of the Belarusan Association of Journalists (BAJ).

On April 25 during the IX Congress of BAJ Zhanna Litvina, who had performed the functions of the head of organization for almost 20 years, resigned from this position to be changed with Andrei Bastunets, who has been working as the deputy chair of BAJ for a long time.

People say that “a new broom sweeps clean”. Is the new chair of BAJ going to change the course of organization, its strategy, and the tactics of action? How independent press is going to answer new challenges and threats, first of all those on the part of the “Russian World”?

The guest of the “EuroBelarus” Information Service is the BAJ leader Andrei Bastunets.

- Will BAJ policy change after your appointment?

- Obviously, no. Neither the policy nor the direction of work will change. Before the elections I was among the managers of the organization and a deputy chair and, accordingly, was responsible for the work of BAJ that was performed earlier.

- What does independent journalism look like today? How do you see situation in independent journalism from the inside – is it a sad or a positive sight?

I wouldn’t use term “sight” in reference to the independent journalism.

What is independent journalism? It is responsible journalism that adheres to the standards of journalist work and performs the mission of media: informing people, providing the platform for expressing opinions of publicly important issues, controlling the actions of the authorities…

Obviously, today’s situation in Belarus is unfavorable for performing these functions of media. But I think that independent media work in this situation with dignity.

- The relations of independent media with the state cannot be called unclouded. But what are the principles that these mutual relations are based at?

- Independent journalism is the general term. And it is clear that every media and every journalist build the relations with the state and with the authorities in their own specific way.

But if we talk in general, the state makes every effort to drive the independent journalism into ghetto; and not only traditional mass media, but also Internet, whereas media community is opposing this pressure.

- On the eve of the professional journalistic holiday the Information Minister announced that the ministry prepared draft changes to the decree that presupposes responsibility of Internet owners for the information disposed at their media. And it looks like it is not the last crackdown on the threshold of the presidential campaign in Belarus.

- Both me and other experts have already noted that the introduction of changes to the law on mass media aroused conflict between the two legal norms. The law on media stipulated liability for the owners of Internet resources for comments that are displaced at their media, whereas the president Decree No.60 said that the responsibility is on those persons that displaced their comments in the Internet.

When there is a conflict between the two norms in Belarus, the authorities prefer to use the tougher one, and that is what the changes to the President Decree are supposed to be about. Though let me note that according to the legislative rules such conflict of norms shouldn’t have appeared. Before taking another norm we should have first abolished the first one. But not so that deputies vote for the norm that contradicts the Presidential Decree, while later he signs the law that contradicts the decree he has signed himself earlier.

I think that now all legal possibilities based on any little reason to stop any traditional media from publishing or blocking any Internet resource are created. We shouldn’t expect new changes to the legislation on mass media, though at the level of law enforcement we can always expect some unpleasant innovations.

- Russia-Ukraine war has created new challenges for the Belarusan journalism, i.e. to withstand aggressive Russian propaganda. Is Belarusan journalism ready to react to the threats of the “Russian World”?

- Few days ago the awarding ceremony of the creative contest for journalists Volnaye Slova (Free Word) took place in BAJ. Yuras Karmanau, president of the jury, noted that almost third part of the works that were sent to the competition and even won prizes were dedicated to the military conflict at the east of Ukraine and were written by independent journalists. It is independent media that formulate Belarusan stance in relation to the Russia-Ukraine war duly. State press, I think, demonstrates complete uncertainty and inability to oppose the Russian propaganda.

Besides, numerous official media were created mainly at the Russian program production. Formally and judicially performing as the Belarusan media, in reality they promote Kremlin’s position. For out of eight Belarusan TV-channels that are a part of the obligatory commonly available package four are using Russian information production.

- The Information Minister called upon Belarusan TV-channels to work for the development of the national information area. One of the creators of the state propaganda – Belarus based Aliaksandr Zimouski – is convinced that Belarus doesn’t have any resources for opposing the Russian propaganda. How grounded are such statements?

- In late May presentation of the work of a group of media experts that study the problem of defending Belarusan national information area will take place. This work is done within the frames of “Reforum” project by BISS aimed at modernization of the Belarusan legislation. The conclusions of the experts haven’t been formed yet, but I can take the liberty of saying that although the system of control over the media sphere is able to block distribution of any information it turns out to be absolutely powerless in the face of total Russian propaganda. Out TV has mastered the art of blocking concrete topics directed against the highest official in the country; but when it faces the ideology of the “Russian World”, even though this ideology might disrupt Belarusan statehood, it is helpless. And that is not surprising, since the whole system of Belarus’ national security is built for being in one bundle with Russia.

- State media are consonant with the Russian propaganda; at least they don’t make any attempts to step out of the Russian information captivity. What goals does independent journalism have in the face of the threat from the “Russian World”?

- We do follow and analyze the situation; we will direct our conclusions and suggestions to the state bodies and voice them publicly, both inside and outside Belarus.

Last year BAJ refused to take part in the Congress organized by the European Federation of Journalists that took place in Moscow. We found it impossible to participate at the time when the information war against Ukraine was launched by numerous Russian media.

BAJ adheres to the very clear position that is not political, but originates from the journalistic standards. We don’t want to support something that has nothing to do with journalism, even if indirectly.

Other news section «Society»

Siarhei Viatohin: Being out of the Bologna Process will leave Belarus with no scientific elite
Siarhei Viatohin: Being out of the Bologna Process will leave Belarus with no scientific elite
"To sign the document, and then to try to wiggle out of implementing what was signed", - the expert of the Public Bologna Committee assesses the reforms of higher education.
Experts: Monitoring street music is a very strange and absurd know-how of officials
Experts: Monitoring street music is a very strange and absurd know-how of officials
Bands will be admitted to play in the underground walkways but only in the 12 permitted areas under the control of the police and with the agreed repertoire.
Uladzimir Matskevich: Litvinism carries the germ of separatism
Uladzimir Matskevich: Litvinism carries the germ of separatism
The Russian forces that specialize in informational war believe that it is already possible to start fire of litvinism in Belarus.
Anatoli Shumchanka: The government pushes entrepreneurs to the protests and politics
Anatoli Shumchanka: The government pushes entrepreneurs to the protests and politics
If the officials do not want to listen to the entrepreneurs, "we have to proceed to the plan "B".
Anton Sidarenka: Belarusians are willing to pay for their own movies
Anton Sidarenka: Belarusians are willing to pay for their own movies
"Our movie" project  started in Minsk: a series of movie screenings and discussions about contemporary independent Belarusian movies with their authors.
Uladzimir Dunaeu: So far our country is falling behind everyone
Uladzimir Dunaeu: So far our country is falling behind everyone
The implementation of the Roadmap for higher education enters its critical phase.
Ales Smalianchuk: Holocaust remembrance says a lot about the Belarusians
Ales Smalianchuk: Holocaust remembrance says a lot about the Belarusians
Belarus had Jewish population for a long time, but how did the war affect their relationship with the Belarusians and what image of the Holocaust is imprinted into the memory of the Belarusians?
Viachaslau Pilipuk: It is more efficient to cooperate with the entrepreneurs than to push them away
Viachaslau Pilipuk: It is more efficient to cooperate with the entrepreneurs than to push them away
The working group of the Ministry of Economy will consider the "National project" of the non-governmental organization "Perspective" on January 30.
Sviatlana Matskevich: Freedom can revive the education
Sviatlana Matskevich: Freedom can revive the education
The lack of reforms in education is a threat: Belarus might lose human capital and face a cultural catastrophe.
Valiantsin Stefanovich: Repressions in Belarus did not disappear
Valiantsin Stefanovich: Repressions in Belarus did not disappear
The introduction of “soft” repressions does not imply the process is irreversible.
Ihar Kuzniatsou: A free person behaving like a slave is a syndrome of the 1937th
Ihar Kuzniatsou: A free person behaving like a slave is a syndrome of the 1937th
Minsk declared 2017 the Year of Commemoration in Memory of the victims of Soviet repressions in Belarus.
Tatiana Shchyttsova: Respect the right of every human life to be a surprise for oneself (Photo)
Tatiana Shchyttsova: Respect the right of every human life to be a surprise for oneself (Photo)
How compatible are the development of biotechnology and human dignity, and what will win?
Uladzimir Dunaeu: The Road map for higher education might not be implemented
Uladzimir Dunaeu: The Road map for higher education might not be implemented
It is necessary for the public to raise its voice to mobilize the educational reforms in Belarus.
Experts: Visa-free regime is good news, but no tourists will come without additional measures
Experts: Visa-free regime is good news, but no tourists will come without additional measures
We must have low cost airlines, unique routes, and authentic recreation to attract the glutted western tourists to Belarus.
Nasta Loika: Human rights revolution has already happened
Nasta Loika: Human rights revolution has already happened
What are the similarities and the distinctions between human rights and anarchism and how these concepts coexist in Belarus and in the world?
Dmitry Drozd: Stalinism gains popularity, but decommunisation is inevitable
Dmitry Drozd: Stalinism gains popularity, but decommunisation is inevitable
It is far from easy to find information about repressions in Belarus. However, we can change the future only by knowing the fate of our ancestors.
Tatsiana Vadalazhskaja: Thinking exists only in the actual intellectual effort
Tatsiana Vadalazhskaja: Thinking exists only in the actual intellectual effort
Thinking related issues exist in all areas, at times even unexpected ones.
Ulad Vialichka: Civil society spent 2016 without vim, but this is no reason for dramatization
Ulad Vialichka: Civil society spent 2016 without vim, but this is no reason for dramatization
The whole country is in crisis, including civil society, but it is “not dead - it is alive and solving pressing issues.”
Uladzimir Matskevich: During 2016 Belarus was in a state of chronic smoldering crisis
Uladzimir Matskevich: During 2016 Belarus was in a state of chronic smoldering crisis
According to the philosopher, the crisis like a disease penetrated into all spheres of life in the country.
Arest Bilaskurski: The more channels the better
Arest Bilaskurski: The more channels the better
The future of the Belarusian TV lies in the development of our own local content.
Gintautas Mažeikis: The relation of political field and arena in the framework of information war

In his report, philosopher Gintautas Mažeikis discusses several concepts that have been a part of the European social and philosophical thought for quite a time.

Uladzimir Matskevich: Lukashenka does not disrupt Russian plans to annex Belarus

But Lukashenka is afraid for his fate and position - he needs Belarus to be sovereign to fully exercise his power.

Tatiana Vadalazhskaya: We see the hunger for intellectual work

Having summarized the results of the “admission campaign”, the organizers were pleasantly amazed at the number of people who showed interest in the Flying University proposals in the new school season

Siarhei Viatohin: Being out of the Bologna Process will leave Belarus with no scientific elite

"To sign the document, and then to try to wiggle out of implementing what was signed", - the expert of the Public Bologna Committee assesses the reforms of higher education.